Does a Victim of Domestic Violence Have to Testify

Testimony from the accuser is often crucial evidence in domestic violence cases. When domestic violence accusers choose not to testify, it can potentially weaken the prosecution's case against the accused. However, many are unaware that once the police are involved, the decision to proceed with charges rests with the county, not the accuser. Regardless of their change of heart, the county can still pursue a domestic violence charge.

Can Domestic Violence Victims Refuse to Testify in Court?

In domestic violence cases, victims do not often choose not to testify. Sometimes, the prosecutor might force the victim to testify by issuing a subpoena, but this can be tricky if the victim is scared or hostile. Plus, if the victim is married to the defendant, they might not be forced to testify due to spousal privilege.

What is Spousal Privilege?

In Arizona, people can legally refuse to testify against their spouse in court. This is known as the spousal testimonial privilege, and it's designed to protect the harmony of marriage by not forcing a person to testify against their spouse. 

However, there are exceptions to this rule in many states when one spouse is accused of a crime against the other, like in cases of domestic violence. In these situations, the prosecutor might be able to force the spouse to testify against the other.

What Happens When a Victim Refuses to Testify in a Domestic Violence Case?

In many domestic violence cases, the testimony of the accuser is crucial. This is because the accuser's testimony is often the most compelling evidence in a domestic violence case, mainly if there were no other witnesses to the alleged incident. If the accuser decides not to testify, it can be challenging for the state to press charges.

However, even if the accuser refuses to testify, the prosecution can still press charges if they believe they have sufficient evidence. This evidence could include the following: 

  • 911 Phone Call Recording: One such form of evidence could be the 911 call made by the accuser. This call, often made in the heat of the moment, can provide valuable insights into the situation at the time of the alleged incident. The tone of the call, the background noises, and the urgency in the accuser's voice can all serve as powerful evidence of the severity of the situation.

  • Medical Records: Medical records can also be crucial in these cases. If the accuser sought medical attention after the alleged incident, the medical records could provide concrete evidence of injuries sustained, which could corroborate the accuser's initial allegations. These records could include everything from doctor's notes to X-rays or photographs of injuries.

  • Statements From Friends and Family: Statements from friends and family can also be used as evidence. These individuals might have witnessed the aftermath of the alleged incident or could provide testimony about the relationship dynamics between the accuser and the accused. Their statements could help paint a picture of a pattern of abuse or violence, further strengthening the prosecution's case.

Even if charges are pressed, the accuser retains the right to refuse to testify. This could weaken the prosecution's case, leaving them with only indirect evidence. Sometimes, the prosecutor can issue a subpoena to compel the accuser to testify. However, this is not ideal, as the accuser might be too frightened, intimidated, or antagonistic to provide strong evidence.

What if the Defendant Has Past Convictions?

When a prosecutor decides whether to move forward with a domestic violence case, they'll closely examine the defendant's past criminal record. They might even use evidence of these past crimes in court, but this depends on Arizona's laws and the prosecutor's specific approach to the case. If the defendant has been convicted of domestic violence, this could play a significant role in the prosecutor's decision.

Witness Intimidation or Tampering

Also, if a defendant tries to scare a victim into not testifying, this is another crime, often known as witness intimidation or tampering. If found guilty of this, the defendant could face severe penalties, especially if they threatened to harm the victim physically. This could even be considered a felony, a more serious type of crime with harsher punishments.

Contact a Domestic Violence Attorney in Phoenix, Arizona

At Bala Legal Services, we are committed to providing exceptional legal support and representation. Attorney Adithya Bala is dedicated to assisting you every step of the way. We believe in being approachable, understanding, and affordable.

We proudly serve the areas of Tempe, Mesa, Scottsdale, Phoenix, and Chandler, and we are well-versed in the local legal landscape. If you are facing criminal charges in Arizona, we are here to help. Contact us today to schedule a free case evaluation.

Top 5 Reasons Why Clients Choose Bala!
Great Value for the Legal Service
Successfully defended hundreds of individuals
Personal Service & Case Strategy
Judge and prosecutor negotiations
Vigorously Protecting your constitutional rights with aggressive defense. (When necessary)

FREE Strategy Call

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Legal Disclaimer:

The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. Bala Legal Services team are licensed to practice law in Arizona. We invite you to contact us, but please be aware that contacting us does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to us until an attorney-client relationship has been established.

SuperLawyers Award
SuperLawyers Award